Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mick Cowan's avatar

What was learnt:

1. The game plan is coming together – With the game at the ‘G, where we had been opened up earlier in the year, it was clear that that connection between backs, mids and forwards has been strengthened since the games earlier in the season. This is both because of player availability, but also the confidence gained in playing together for a significant run of games. It is reflected in the total disposals 358 for 63 inside 50s which also meant an efficiency I50 of 54%. When you think about the early part of the season as to the number of shots we took wide of the centre corridor, it certainly assists in kicking 100+ points in the past two games.

2. Whether it’s 17 or 7, the ruck position is well served – Whilst it is each to their own as to whether you prefer 7 or 17, the fact that we have two more than serviceable ruck options means that we should be able to have a midfield that will be more than competitive for the remainder of the season.

3. Clean centre clearances are “gold” – For the second game in a row, it is clear as to how valuable it is for the midfield to come out the front of the centre square to set up scoring opportunities for our forwards. I had 6 goals resulting from centre square takeaways. Admittedly, the Crows were missing their break away midfielder, but you can only beat what is in front of you.

4. The “Hawks surge” – Often, there is much made of the “orange tsunami”, the “Hawks surge” (whatever it may be called) will become a feature for fans to look forward to him the coming seasons with Weddle, Impey, Amon & Sicily coming off half back to provide overlap run. There is still some refinement to the final entry at times, however the dash through the lines is an exciting brand to watch.

5. “Kill the body and the mind will follow”/ “Failure cannot overcome perseverance” – Two lines Allan Jeans was known to share with his players, and this applied to the game yesterday with the level of tackling and pressure bringing the Crows to a level of indecision that we have seen ourselves over the past couple of seasons. This level of commitment would’ve been relished by the 2014 premiership players in attendance.

6. For Day to take the next step, it is his goalkicking that needs to improve – Having had three reasonable opportunities to hit the scoreboard for a return of one behind, Day just needs to be more settled in taking his opportunities. Running inside 50 with 3 bounces for no result isn’t reflective of his usual assuredness with the ball. (Note: A similar critique can be made of C. Macdonald, although he took a left foot shot this week.)

7. There is a time to play tempo footy – In the 3rd quarter where the Crows had some momentum, Impey was able to take an intercept mark from a Crows exit from their defence on the MCC members’ side; however rather than taking his time and allow the forwards and defenders to set up, he immediately kicked it forward which was intercepted which led to the defence being caught offside.

Observations:

• At this stage of his career, Dear needs to be hit up either on the lead or have a chance to launch at the ball; to drop the ball on top of his head doesn’t give him his best chance without a strong core to hold off defenders. His kicking is still a work in progress.

• Ginnivan had a day of mixed fortunes as has been well noted. What slipped by were a couple of his poor field kicking where he missed targets over about 20m.

• Mitchell confused “ambition and ability” on the one set play kick out opportunity; having taken the mark the thought that he could out race his opponent, only to be caught. He then went to ground “too readily” which left him open to the holding the ball (dragging it in) decision which was more a penalty for “stupidity” as the Crows’ opponent dragged it under him. At times, he is “overzealous” in his approach to the contest and just needs to take a more measured approach i.e. play the percentages playing as a defender.

• A couple of key plays by Frost deserve mention – a sweeping handball in the 2nd quarter rather than a kick showed some thought; and then in the last quarter, he ran about 40 metres to make a contest on Burgess who had been left off the chain in a Crows’ overlap run.

• Breust missing two snaps in the last quarter is not something you’d see all that often let alone on Jack’s big day!

• There may be some further credit due to the recruiters, although I’m not sure it was ever a genuine choice; however with the Suns looking to offload both Burgess and Chol last year, I’d suggest that if there was choice to be made, then the right one was made.

Starting 4:

1st qtr.: Worpel (21) Day (24) Newcombe (25)

2nd qtr.: Nash ((18) Day Newcombe

3rd qtr.: Worpel Day Newcombe

4th qtr.: Worpel Day Newcombe

(Reeves 22, Chol 9, Moore 3, Mackenzie 2)

(Note: A heavier focus on the Big 4 this week.)

Coach killers:

Giving up another shot at goal for an off the ball skirmish – with the depth of the squad improving, I doubt that Sam won’t think twice about wielding the selection axe for those who can’t play to the team’s benefit.

Issue for the week:

How long can Breust as sub be the selection strategy? With the manner in which Ward, Wingard, Watson and a few others played against Essendon for BH, along with their ability to play in other positions, will the need for greater sub flexibility become an issue for the remainder of the season.

Expand full comment
Graeme's avatar

Tremendous review again Mick. Watson was good today…creates a lot of forward pressure. The forgotten man DGB was very solid today too. Agree Reeves was very honest today but I’m a 17 fan. More strings to his bow. Mt quiet watch for a player of the future is Bodie Ryan.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts