Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Andrew Town's avatar

Some of your finest work gents. Captured the joy of the season and the game.

Looking forward to you carrying your form into the finals

Expand full comment
Stuart McKenzie's avatar

Thanks for another terrific summary Mick and the stats on the rolling % and quarters won - more gold from you. Quarters won is seen by many as a key indicator of a side’s overall performance and competitiveness. To have won only 4 less quarters over the season than the minor premier and premiership favourite is an exceptional achievement and is hopefully a marker of the quality of our team.

Once again, our small forwards showed just what a weapon they are, both as individuals and as a collective. What’s so good about this group is not only their current output but there is real upside – Watson is 19, Ginnivan is 21, McDonald is 21 and at 24, Dylan Moore is the ‘old boy’, this quartet has further improvement. Having watched quite a lot of Box Hill, (albeit via streaming), Jack O’Sullivan really has something to offer, but he’s just not going to get an opportunity unless there’s an injury.

The quality of our small forwards highlights the importance of competing aerially in our front half to bring the ball to ground. next week against the Dogs If we can deny Jones and Lobb intercept marks, the boys can then get to work at ground level. We also want Meeky to rip into English from the very start.

As Mick says, if CJ and Day are available, they have to be picked. As good as Harry has been, he’s had the benefit of playing in three games that we’ve won very comfortably and while he’s a good back up ‘soldier’, he doesn’t have the attributes that CJ does. While our midfield was superior on Saturday, this challenge gets tougher each week. My fear is that if Jai is tagged out of the game (which happened most recently at Geelong), without Will Day, we’re suddenly reliant on Worps and Nashy. As good as those boys have been for us this year, they’ll be swamped by Bont, Libba, Richards, Treloar etc. If Day doesn’t play, we need some contingencies for the likely scenario where Jai is heavily tagged.

Was it just me being grumpy or was it disappointing that there was no coverage at all of Liam Shiels farewell (and just the general reaction of our players and coaches post-game), as Fox switched immediately to the Richmond v GCS game. Also, was there any interaction at all between Clarko and Sam post-game, especially when Shiels was chaired off? The fanfare accorded to the three Richmond retirees and to Dyson Heppel seemed disproportionate.

That was also a nice touch from the HI team to nominate Damien Barrett as under pressure. He’ll never come out and admit that the decisions to move Mitchell and O’Meara on and, albeit reluctantly, trade Gunston and ‘retire’ several other older players, including Big Boy and Kyle Hartigan were correct. His suggestion that these list management decisions amounted to tanking was ridiculous and if that was the purpose it was quite a fail as we ‘tanked’ the season to get pick number 7.

Whatever happens from here, it’s been a magical season and we shouldn’t forget that. But right now, it's time to dream.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts